On September 7, 1876, Jesse James and his notorious gang attempted what they thought would be their greatest heist in the quiet town of Northfield, Minnesota. Instead, they met their greatest disaster.
The James-Younger Gang had robbed banks and trains across the frontier for over a decade. They were confident, experienced, and ready for their biggest score yet.
But when the shooting started, ordinary citizens grabbed guns and fought back with extraordinary courage.
What began as a routine robbery became a street battle that changed Wild West history forever.
Contents
The James-Younger Gang: America’s Most Notorious Outlaws
The James-Younger gang emerged from Missouri’s brutal Civil War guerrilla warfare, led by brothers Jesse and Frank James alongside the Younger brothers – Cole, Jim, John, and Bob.
From 1866 to 1881, they terrorized the Midwest with a string of bank and train robberies, becoming folk heroes to some and ruthless criminals to others.
Their guerilla-style military training, honed and perfected while serving with Quantrill’s Raiders during the Civil War, made them exceptionally skilled at hit-and-run tactics.
The gang’s reign of terror finally unraveled during their disastrous 1876 Northfield raid, which scattered the survivors and marked the beginning of their end.
Jesse James: The Face of the Wild West Outlaw
Born in Missouri in 1847, Jesse James learned violence during the brutal Civil War.
As a teenager, he joined Confederate guerrilla units fighting behind Union lines, witnessing terrible atrocities and participating in deadly raids.
When the war ended, Jesse couldn’t adjust to civilian life. He gathered fellow Confederate veterans and began robbing banks across the Midwest.
His daring daylight robberies made headlines nationwide, turning him into both folk hero and public enemy. By 1876, his name was known in every American household.
The Gang Structure
Frank James, Jesse’s older brother, served as the steady leader who balanced Jesse’s impulsive nature.
The gang included other dangerous men like Clell Miller, known for his quick draw, and Bill Chadwell, who brought crucial local knowledge of Minnesota.
Operating like a military unit reflecting their Civil War backgrounds, they planned carefully, moved quickly, and supported each other under pressure.
This teamwork had made them successful for years, but also made them fatally overconfident.
Planning the Raid
Why Northfield Bank?
Northfield’s First National Bank attracted the gang because of its reputation as the biggest bank west of the Mississippi, holding enormous amounts of cash from the prosperous farming community.
The town’s remote location meant slow law enforcement response, and multiple escape routes led through rural areas.
Bill Chadwell convinced the others this would be their easiest job yet, describing Northfield as a sleepy farm town where no one would expect famous outlaws.
But their intelligence proved fatally incomplete—they knew about the money but didn’t understand the character of the people.
The September 7th Plan
Three men would enter the bank: Jesse James, Frank James, and one other. The remaining gang members would control the street outside, preventing interference and ensuring escape routes.
They expected to find a full vault and minimal resistance from surprised townspeople.
Their fatal error was assuming Northfield citizens would react like victims in previous robberies.
Most people in other towns had hidden or fled when outlaws appeared.
But Northfield attracted educated, civic-minded settlers who felt strong connections to their community—many were Civil War veterans unafraid of gunfire.
September 7, 1876: The Northfield Raid Unfolds
The Bank Assault
At 2:00 PM, Jesse James and two companions walked into the First National Bank while associates took positions outside.
But something was different from the start—instead of cowering, bank employees looked for opportunities to resist.
Joseph Lee Heywood, the acting cashier, refused to open the vault despite direct threats to his life.
When demanded to cooperate, he calmly lied that it was locked on a time delay.
Even with a gun to his head, he refused to budge, buying precious time for the town to organize resistance.
The Town Fights Back
Word spread quickly through Northfield. Instead of hiding, townspeople grabbed weapons and converged on the bank.
Hardware store owner J.S. Allen armed neighbors with rifles and shotguns. Medical student Henry Wheeler climbed to a second-story window to shoot down at gang members.
Citizens took cover and returned fire.
The coordinated response caught the gang completely off guard. They faced an entire community fighting with the determination of people defending their homes.
The carefully planned raid became chaotic retreat under heavy fire.
Disaster and Aftermath
The street fighting proved deadly for the gang. Clell Miller and Bill Chadwell—the man who had recommended Northfield—both died in the battle.
Other members suffered serious wounds that slowed their escape.
Joseph Lee Heywood was shot and killed by frustrated outlaws as their plan collapsed, but his sacrifice had saved the town’s money and inspired the resistance.
The Failed Escape
Surviving gang members fled in complete disarray, abandoning their escape plans.
Minnesota authorities organized massive manhunts with hundreds of volunteers. Telegraph messages spread word across the state, making the famous outlaws easy to identify and impossible to hide.
The Younger brothers were captured after a gunfight with pursuing lawmen, ending their criminal careers in Minnesota prisons.
Other gang members died from wounds or were shot resisting capture. Jesse and Frank James managed to escape to Missouri, but their lives as successful bank robbers were over.
Related: 13 Female Gunslingers Who Made the West Truly Wild
Legacy and Cultural Impact
The Great Northfield Raid marked the end of the Wild West outlaw era. Citizens had proven that organized resistance could defeat even the most notorious criminals.
The story inspired the 1972 Hollywood film starring Cliff Robertson and continues to be retold in books, documentaries, and annual reenactments in Northfield.
The Northfield Historical Society preserves the memory through exhibits, educational programs, and September reenactments that draw thousands of visitors every year.
The story endures because it represents the triumph of ordinary citizens over notorious criminals, showing how communities can protect themselves through determination and courage.
Wrapping it Up
The Great Northfield Raid became Jesse James’ most famous failure because it revealed the limits of outlaw power and the strength of community resistance.
A small Minnesota town transformed itself into legend by refusing to be intimidated by America’s most notorious criminals.
Joseph Lee Heywood’s heroic sacrifice and the citizens’ courageous street fighting proved that organized resistance could defeat any threat.
After Northfield, outlaw gangs could no longer count on terrorizing peaceful communities.
The bank robbery that went wrong marked the end of an era and continues to inspire anyone who faces overwhelming odds and refuses to surrender.
Frequently Asked Questions
What happened to Frank James the outlaw?
Frank James surrendered to Missouri Governor Thomas T. Crittenden in 1882, five months after his brother Jesse’s assassination. He was tried for various crimes but never convicted. After his acquittal, Frank lived quietly as a farmer, worked various jobs including theater security, and died peacefully in 1915 at age 72.
What happened to the Younger brothers after the Northfield Raid?
After the Northfield Raid, Cole, Jim, and Bob Younger were captured, wounded, and sentenced to life in prison at Stillwater State Prison in Minnesota. Bob died in prison in 1889. Jim and Cole were paroled in 1901, with Jim later committing suicide in 1902 and Cole living until 1916.
Was the Great Northfield Minnesota Raid true?
Yes, the Great Northfield Minnesota Raid was a real historical event that occurred on September 7, 1876. The Jesse James-Younger gang attempted to rob the First National Bank of Northfield but were thwarted by armed townspeople. The failed robbery became legendary in American outlaw history.
How many were killed in the Northfield raid?
The Northfield raid of September 7, 1876, resulted in the deaths of two townspeople – Nicholas Gustafson and Joseph Lee Heywood, a bank cashier who refused to open the vault. Two members of the Jesse James-Younger gang were also killed during the failed bank robbery attempt in Minnesota.
Article Sources
- Minnesota Historical Society. (n.d.). Northfield bank raid. MNopedia. https://www3.mnhs.org/mnopedia/search/index/event/northfield-bank-raid
- Northfield Historical Society. (n.d.). 1876 bank raid. Northfield Historical Society. https://www.northfieldhistory.org/1876-bank-raid
- Office of the Comptroller of the Currency. (n.d.). Attack on Northfield National Bank. In History of the OCC: 1866-1913. U.S. Department of the Treasury. https://occ.gov/about/who-we-are/history/history-of-the-occ/1866-1913/1866-1913-attack-on-northfield-national-bank.html
- Oklahoma Historical Society. (n.d.). Quantrill’s Raiders. The Encyclopedia of Oklahoma History and Culture. https://www.okhistory.org/publications/enc/entry?entry=QU002